When pay rises are modest, reward communication means everything

For most employees, pay is the main reason they turn up to work.

Culture, flexibility, purpose and progression all matter, but salary pays the bills and supports people’s lives outside work. So when pay rises are modest, HR and Reward teams need to tread carefully.

As employers plan their reward budgets for 2027, many are balancing employee expectations against rising employment costs and tighter budgets.

Brightmine’s latest pay forecast predicts a median pay award of 3% for the year to August 2027. Separate research from Incomes Data Research found that 60% of employers expect their 2027 increase to fall between 3% and 3.99%, with affordability influencing the decisions of 97% of organisations surveyed.

That leaves HR and Reward teams with a difficult communication challenge.

When pay increases are modest, how do you help employees understand the wider value of their reward package without making it sound as though benefits are being offered in place of fair pay?

A Total Reward Statement can help, but only when it is communicated clearly and honestly.

Pay still comes first

Benefits can add considerable value to the employee experience, but they do not replace salary.

An employee worried about rising household costs is unlikely to feel reassured by being reminded about a discount platform they rarely use. Equally, presenting the total cost of employment as though it is the same as take-home pay risks undermining trust rather than strengthening it.

A Total Reward Statement should not be used to convince employees that they ought to feel differently about a pay decision.

Its role is to give them a clearer and more complete view of what they receive from the organisation.

That includes salary, but it may also include employer pension contributions, bonuses, healthcare, insurance, wellbeing support, additional leave, flexible working, learning opportunities and other benefits.

Seeing those elements together gives employees a fuller picture of what they receive from their employer. But it should never be used to suggest that benefits make up for a disappointing pay decision.

Make the full reward package visible

Salary is easy to see. It appears in job offers, contracts, payslips and bank accounts.

The rest of the reward package can be considerably less visible.

Pension contributions may sit with one provider. Healthcare information may be held somewhere else. Details about wellbeing support might be on the intranet, while an employee’s annual reward statement is buried in an old email.

Even valuable benefits can become easy to overlook when the information is scattered across different systems.

A personalised Total Reward Statement brings these elements together. It allows employees to see their salary alongside the wider package provided by their employer, without having to search in several places.

This can be particularly important when pay budgets are under pressure. If an organisation is investing in its employees beyond salary, that investment should be visible and easy to understand.

Otherwise, there is a gap between what the employer provides and what employees recognise they receive.

Communicate value without overselling it

Clear Total Reward communication should help employees understand their package without making exaggerated claims about its value.

That means being transparent about what each element represents.

For example:

  • Which rewards have a clear financial value?
  • Which benefits are paid for or subsidised by the employer?
  • Which elements depend on performance or eligibility?
  • Which benefits are available but have not been selected?
  • Which parts of the employee experience have value but cannot sensibly be reduced to a monetary figure?

Flexible working, development opportunities and additional leave may be extremely important to employees. That does not mean HR needs to attach an inflated financial figure to each one.

Sometimes the value lies in making the benefit visible, explaining how it works and helping employees understand when it might be useful.

Plain English also matters. Employees should not need a background in HR, pensions or finance to make sense of their own reward package.

Make Total Reward personal

A generic list of company benefits tells an employee what the organisation offers. A personalised Total Reward Statement tells them what they receive. That is a much more meaningful conversation.

Employees have different priorities depending on their circumstances. One person may be particularly interested in pension contributions, while another values healthcare, family support, flexible working or opportunities for development.

A good TRS should make an employee’s existing package clear while also helping them discover relevant benefits they may not have selected or fully understood.

Strait Logics’ Total Reward functionality can highlight benefits an employee has not enrolled in, giving HR an opportunity to increase awareness without overwhelming people with every available option at once.

The aim is not to make the package appear as large as possible but rather to make it relevant and understandable to the person viewing it.

Move beyond the annual PDF

Timing also affects how employees perceive reward.

An annual statement may contain useful information, but much of it will be forgotten if employees open it once and then file it away. Reward becomes relevant at different moments throughout the year.

An employee might want to review their pension before changing their contribution. They may look for healthcare support when their circumstances change, revisit family benefits when planning parental leave or check their overall package before making a career decision.

An online, always-available TRS gives employees somewhere to return to whenever that information becomes relevant.

It also gives HR a more useful communication channel. Rather than relying on one annual event, teams can highlight particular benefits, support enrolment periods and keep reward information up to date.

We explored this further in our article, Are your Total Reward Statements actually working?.

Use reward communication to build trust

Let’s be honest. Employees are unlikely to object to being given clear information about their full package.

Problems arise when Total Reward communication feels like an attempt to distract from concerns about pay. The tone should therefore be factual, open and respectful.

If pay budgets are constrained, explain the wider context where appropriate. If the organisation continues to invest in benefits, show employees what is available and how to access it. If parts of the package are changing, communicate those changes clearly rather than allowing employees to discover them by accident.

Employees do not need every message to tell them how fortunate they are. They need accurate information that helps them understand what they receive and make informed choices.

Handled well, a Total Reward Statement can support that transparency. It can show the wider package without pretending that every element carries the same weight as salary.

Review whether the communication is working

Having a TRS means little if you don’t use it to its full potential. HR teams should look at whether employees are using it, what information they view and where questions or misunderstandings remain.

Useful measures might include:

  • How many employees access their Total Reward Statement
  • Whether they return at different points during the year
  • Which benefits attract attention
  • Whether employees understand their overall package
  • Whether routine reward and benefits questions to HR decrease
  • Whether employees know how to access the benefits available to them
  • What employees say about the clarity and relevance of the information

But these are just examples as it will be unique to each organisation. The right measures will depend on what the organisation wants its TRS to achieve.

Our recent blog, How to measure the ROI of a Total Reward Statementlooks at this in more detail.

Questions to ask before finalising your 2027 reward communications

As plans for 2027 take shape, HR and Reward teams may find it useful to ask:

  • Can employees see their full reward package in one place?
  • Is salary clearly distinguished from benefits and other rewards?
  • Does the information reflect what each employee actually receives?
  • Are benefits explained in clear, everyday language?
  • Can employees access the information when they need it?
  • Are unselected or less visible benefits being communicated effectively?
  • Does the tone inform employees without overselling the package?
  • Can HR see whether employees are engaging with the information?

These questions will not solve the wider challenge of constrained pay budgets. They can, however, help ensure that the investment an organisation is already making is understood.

Clear communication matters when budgets are under pressure

When pay increases are limited, it can be tempting to place more emphasis on benefits and wider reward. That needs to be handled carefully. Benefits should not be positioned as compensation for inadequate pay, and a Total Reward Statement should never be used to gloss over difficult decisions.

But employees should still be able to see the full picture.

A clear, personalised and always-available TRS can bring salary, pension contributions, benefits and wider rewards together without confusing or overstating their value. That gives employees better information and gives HR a more credible way to communicate the organisation’s investment in its people.

Help employees understand their full reward package

Strait Logics helps organisations bring pay, benefits and wider reward together in a clear, personalised Total Reward experience that employees can access throughout the year.

Explore Total Reward with Strait Logics

Book a demo